As Audi prepares for its official entry into Formula 1 in 2026, the pressure is mounting for Sauber to choose its drivers wisely for the transitional 2025 season. The upcoming year is critical for Audi as they make the shift from Sauber to Audi works status, and the second seat alongside the experienced Nico Hülkenberg remains the only vacancy that isn't directly under Red Bull’s control. While incumbent Valtteri Bottas seems like a strong candidate, new young talents like Franco Colapinto and Gabriel Bortoleto have emerged as exciting alternatives. So, who should Audi choose to drive alongside Hülkenberg in 2025?
Experience and Continuity
Valtteri Bottas is a seasoned driver with 10 grand prix wins under his belt, and his familiarity with Sauber is a key asset. As Audi seeks to fine-tune its preparations for 2026, Bottas could provide the necessary stability and continuity during this transitional phase. One of the key arguments in favor of Bottas is his experience and ability to work within a team that's in the midst of a significant transformation.
Motorsport journalist Edd Straw highlights Bottas' critical role, emphasizing that the Finnish driver offers not only speed but also continuity. “Bottas has team experience, and that’s invaluable during this time. Audi will need a driver who knows the team inside out and can provide feedback that accelerates their transition to a full works team in 2026,” Straw argues. Bottas has been with Sauber since 2022, and his extensive F1 experience means he can bring the calm, composed guidance the team needs.
Another significant aspect of Bottas’ candidacy is his familiarity with the operational inefficiencies at Sauber. As Audi steps in, having a driver who understands the challenges the team has faced and who can offer insights into solving them is critical. While Bottas may not be the flashiest choice, he offers experience that Audi could leverage to sharpen up the team, particularly during its transition period.
The Rising Star with Immediate F1 Impact
Franco Colapinto, the Argentine driver currently standing in for Williams, has quickly made his mark in Formula 1. Despite his mid-season entry, Colapinto’s performances have turned heads, prompting many to consider him a top contender for the Sauber seat. His pace at Monza and Baku demonstrated that he can compete at the highest level, matching or even outpacing his experienced teammate Alex Albon.
Colapinto's appeal comes from his youthful energy combined with composure under pressure. He impressed during his first few races, including a standout performance in Singapore where he was on course to beat Albon before the latter retired from the race. The 21-year-old’s ability to adapt quickly to the demands of F1 signals that he may have the potential to be a generational talent, a factor that Audi must consider as it looks to establish itself in the sport.
Mitchell-Malm, a prominent F1 analyst, strongly supports Colapinto's candidacy, stating, “He’s a driver for the future. Audi needs to think long-term, and Colapinto gives them that opportunity. His performances with Williams have shown he’s F1-worthy right out of the gate, and Sauber should capitalize on that.” The key question for Audi is whether they want to invest in a young driver with untapped potential or stick with an established, experienced candidate like Bottas.
The Young Gun with an Even Higher Ceiling?
Another exciting option for Audi is McLaren junior driver Gabriel Bortoleto. At just 19 years old, Bortoleto is leading the Formula 2 standings and has delivered some truly impressive performances, including a pole position on his F2 debut, a feat that puts him in the same category as drivers like Charles Leclerc. Bortoleto’s ability to manage high-pressure environments and pull off spectacular drives, such as his last-to-first victory at Monza, makes him an intriguing candidate.
Josh Suttill, another F1 expert, believes that Bortoleto could bring the kind of raw talent Audi needs if it wants to aim for long-term success. “Bortoleto is younger than Colapinto, and his ceiling might be even higher. He’s had an outstanding F2 season and is very much on McLaren’s radar. If Audi wants to invest in youth, Bortoleto would be an exciting choice,” says Suttill.
The challenge, however, lies in Bortoleto’s ties to McLaren. Audi would need to offer serious compensation to pry him away from McLaren’s grasp, but with Bortoleto's career being managed by none other than Fernando Alonso's team, there may be pathways to negotiation. Alonso has proven his ability to navigate out of tricky contractual situations, and his influence could play a key role in securing a deal for Audi.
The Legacy Option with a Fresh Start?
Mick Schumacher, currently competing in the World Endurance Championship (WEC) with Alpine, has found his name linked with Audi's second seat for their anticipated 2026 Formula 1 entry. Schumacher's F1 journey, notably marked by his tenure with Haas, presented numerous challenges. Despite showing promise during his time in Formula 2, where he clinched the championship in 2020, his transition to F1 wasn't as smooth. His struggles at Haas, which ranged from on-track errors to difficulty adapting to the car's performance, left his future in the sport uncertain after his departure from the team.
However, the potential Audi drive represents more than just another chance at F1; it signals a perfect blend of opportunity and symbolism. Audi's German heritage aligns seamlessly with Schumacher's background, as his father, Michael Schumacher, remains a towering figure in the sport. For Mick, re-entering the F1 grid with a team backed by Audi's financial and technical resources could give him the platform needed to fulfill the potential many still see in him. His availability, combined with his German nationality, makes him a strategic option for a team looking to connect with local fans and market themselves as a symbol of national pride.
The prospect of continuing the Schumacher legacy is not just an emotional selling point but a marketing dream for Audi. The name 'Schumacher' holds significant weight in F1 circles, and having Mick as part of the team could bolster Audi's presence and appeal within the sport, particularly in Germany. Moreover, his experiences at Haas, while difficult, may have given Mick valuable insights and the resilience needed to handle the rigors of a high-profile team like Audi. Joining a fresh project with Audi might also allow him to grow in a more stable and supportive environment, free from the intense pressure he faced early in his career.
Mick's future with Audi would also represent a narrative of redemption. A second chance in F1, particularly under a prominent banner like Audi, could enable him to establish his place on the grid, not just as Michael Schumacher's son, but as a capable driver in his own right. Given Audi’s ambitions to be competitive by 2026, the potential pairing could prove beneficial for both sides—Mick gets the opportunity for a fresh start, while Audi benefits from the Schumacher legacy and the national pride associated with it.
A Tempting Return for a German Icon?
Sebastian Vettel, who retired at the end of 2022, has also been linked to Audi’s 2025 driver lineup. Though currently out of the sport, rumors suggest that the four-time world champion could be tempted back, especially for a high-profile project like Audi’s F1 entry. If Audi is aiming for a German national identity, pairing Vettel with Nico Hülkenberg would create one of the most experienced and respected lineups in the paddock. Vettel's return would mirror the comeback of Fernando Alonso, who rejoined the grid after a brief retirement. With Audi’s long-term ambitions, Vettel’s technical expertise and leadership could be invaluable in shaping the car's development for 2026 and beyond.
Balancing Experience and Future Potential
Audi faces a critical decision in choosing its second driver for the 2025 season. Valtteri Bottas offers the reliability and continuity that any team in transition would value, while Franco Colapinto and Gabriel Bortoleto provide youthful energy and long-term potential. Mick Schumacher and Sebastian Vettel present wild-card options that could reignite Audi’s future as an F1 powerhouse with German pedigree.
Ultimately, the decision will depend on Audi’s long-term vision. Do they prioritize immediate progress with experienced drivers like Bottas or Vettel? Or do they invest in youth, potentially fast-tracking Colapinto or Bortoleto into F1 stardom?
With Nico Hülkenberg already in place as Audi’s first official driver, the second seat is a pivotal piece in the puzzle for the future of the team. Audi has a unique opportunity to shape its F1 identity, and whoever they choose for 2025 will play a key role in determining how successful that transition will be.
Comments